On page 311, the way Marjane acts - how she drinks and
parties at Ali's house after Farzad died, is similar to the incident on page
143, when Marjane resorts to rebellious behavior after the death of Neda
Baba-Levy. The way Marjane describes her state of mind after knowing the
missile destroyed her neighbor's house is similar to how she feels on page 311:
"After the death of Neda Baba-Levy, my life took a new turn. In 1984, I
was fourteen and a rebel. Nothing scared me anymore"(143). The death of
Farzad is a confirmation of the extreme views of the Iranian regime and how
they haven't changed since the past. This tragic event serves as a reminder of
the missile explosion incident, and reinforces the fear of the consequences of
partying indoors. The way the Iranian regime still held their extreme views
after Marjane had changed her identity proves that no matter how she tries to
better herself, it won’t necessarily change the way society perceives her; even
though she’s “[taken herself] in hand”(273); as long as she is still repressed
by the regime, she ultimately feels that she has no real control over herself and her views (they aren't being taken into account). Although Marjane voices out her feminist views in public (such as on page 297), she ultimately feels "controlled" by the government when it acts according to its extreme views (this is emphasized when many high school and college students were imprisoned and executed as a result of their demonstrations (page 302), and when Farzad died). This is seen on page 311 when Marjane and her friends are reacting to the disastrous previous night, and in the last panel when Marjane drinks - an act of temporary relief that isn't true to her identity, and shows her rebellious attitude: "I never drank so much in my life"(311). (Although she changed her outlook and voiced out her feminist views in public, the regime still responds in the same controlling manner.)
Although I agree with you about Marjane feeling subordinate, I believe she has remained true to her self. --She voices her opinion and is not afraid of doing so. After page 296, Marjane points out her objection to the laws and is in turn "warned" by her executioner, yet she continues to act on her own belief(s).
ReplyDeleteI admit that the deaths of Marjane's friends (and even uncle) affect her belief about the religion and society a lot. However, I disagree with your last opinion that "as long as she is still repressed by the regime, she feels that she has no control over herself and her identity." Personally I think Marjane is in the process from the teenager to an adult. She is suffering about the idea right and wrong of the world and the harsh reality. I believe when she got older and experience more- also have deeper knowlegde of the social norm, she sure will have better idea about her identity and learn to control herself.
ReplyDelete